Surveying the Opinion of Chemists

As part of a project I was wondering about reports of surveys that collected chemists assessments of differnt things. More specifically, I wasn’t looking for crowd-sourcing efforts for data curation (such as the in the Spectral Game) or data collection. Rather, I was interested in reports where somebody asked a group of chemists what they thought of some particular molecular “feature”. Here, “feature” is pretty broadly defined and could range from the quality of a probe molecule to whether a molecule is complex or not.

Surveying the literature (and with pointers from @dgelemi, @baoilleach, Jun Li, @georgeisyourman and @DrBostrom) here’s the following papers:

The number of people surveyed across these studies ranges from less than 10 to more than 300. Recently there appears to be a trend towards developing predictive models based on the results of such surveys. Also, molecular complexity seems pretty popular. Modeling opinion is always a tricky thing, though in my mind some aspects (e.g., complexity, diversity) lend themselves to more robust models than others (e.g., quality of a probe).

If there are other examples of such surveys in chemistry, I’d appreciate any pointers

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *